First roll controversy

I need help on a discussion I has with my brother. We are both passionate when playing.

It was the first roll of the game where both players roll one dice. I threw a 1 and his dice was tilted, so I picked up my dice and threw it, and he stated that because only his dice was tilted then only he had to roll again, not me.

Evidently, I wanted a new throw and evidently he wanted the 1 to stay.

So question is, are both dice rolled as I claimed? or just his as he did?

The 1 that you rolled stays, there was nothing wrong with the roll.

JLee

Totally agree with JLee